When Connecticut Democrats accuse Republicans of being a “do-nothing” party that votes no to everything, voters should ask about HB 5374.
On that bill, Republicans said yes in overwhelming numbers. Unfortunately, that was a vote we wish more of them had questioned.
HB 5374, now Public Act 26-33, expands the definition of infertility used in Connecticut’s insurance coverage mandates. Beginning January 1, 2027, that definition expressly includes needing donor eggs or sperm, donor embryos, or a gestational surrogate to establish a pregnancy, individually or with a partner. Single men, including “trans-women”, unable to secure a partner, will now be helped to buy a baby in CT and raise them without any oversight. No mother involved, CT families are going to pay for newborns to be created and handed over to single men in our state.
The vote was hardly partisan gridlock. The House passed the bill 140–8, with 42 of its 49 Republicans voting yes. The Senate passed it 36–0, with all 11 Republican senators voting yes.
Democrats know this was bipartisan. Democratic Rep. Raghib Allie-Brennan publicly credited Republican Rep. Tammy Nuccio with helping lead the legislation. His own explanation specifically mentioned donor embryos, donor gametes and surrogacy.

So much for Republicans refusing to cooperate.
But cooperation is only a virtue when the policy deserves support.
The desire for a child can be profound, and infertility can bring terrible grief. Families deserve compassion. Every child, however conceived, deserves love and protection. None of that requires us to accept the idea that adults are entitled to obtain a baby through any means necessary—or that other families should help finance the sometimes immoral medical procedures (including abortion) that make it possible.
From FIC’s perspective, commercial surrogacy reduces the creation and transfer of a child to a transaction. Calling it “family building” does not answer the moral objection . . . children are persons, not products, and women are not wombs for hire.
Let’s be precise about what legislators approved. This law does not expressly require insurers to pay a surrogate’s compensation or an agency’s fees. It expands eligibility for “medically necessary” fertility procedures by bringing a “need” for a surrogate into the statutory definition of infertility – even if that “need” is based on old age, inability to find a willing partner of the opposite sex, or simply not engaging in procreative intercourse. Basically, we are now paying for the creation of babies who will never know a mother’s love. This is truly sad.
There is also an affordability question. Expanded benefits have to be financed. According to one estimate, this law increased premiums for a family of four by hundreds of dollars each year.
Lawmakers cannot simply announce a benefit and act as though nobody else will receive the bill. Voters struggling to afford their own health coverage deserve an explanation of the likely cost—and strong voices from either party who will serve their interests as well.
FIC Action raised concerns about this expansion in testimony submitted by our Director of Public Policy. We warned that the bill will expand subsidized assisted reproduction beyond diagnosed medical infertility and increase the use of surrogacy procedures and the surrogacy industry in CT.
Our position does not change with the party label next to a legislator’s name. Democrats who supported this policy should answer for it. Republicans who supported it should answer for it, too.
The “do-nothing” accusation invites voters to judge legislators by how often they say yes. That is the wrong standard. Voters should judge what they said yes to, what it costs, and whom it protects.
On HB 5374, most Republicans joined Democrats. That undermines the campaign slogan. It also raises a harder question for both parties: Why did so many lawmakers support expanding insurance subsidies for procedures connected to surrogacy?
Sometimes the responsible vote is no.



